The Catholic Church in Italy has stated that homosexual men can train to become priests, provided they do not openly promote or support “gay culture.” This announcement comes from new guidelines issued by the Italian Bishops’ Conference and approved by the Vatican, sparking fresh discussions about inclusivity within the Church.
The 68-page document, published on Thursday, emphasizes the need for celibacy while opening the door for gay men to attend seminaries—institutions that train young men for priesthood. However, it includes specific restrictions for candidates with deeply rooted homosexual tendencies or those who openly advocate for LGBTQ+ causes.
“The Church, while profoundly respecting the persons in question, cannot admit to the seminary and to Holy Orders those who practise homosexuality, present deeply rooted homosexual tendencies, or support the so-called gay culture,” the guidelines state.
Call for Chastity and Celibacy
The document stresses that the goal of priestly training is to help candidates embrace chastity and celibacy as gifts from God. “The ability to accept as a gift, to freely choose and live chastity in celibacy, is fundamental to priesthood,” it reads.
This announcement aligns with broader Church teachings on celibacy but raises questions about the balance between respecting individual identities and adhering to traditional doctrines.
Pope Francis’ Inclusive Stance and Controversy
Pope Francis, who has gained a reputation for promoting a more inclusive Church, has previously expressed a compassionate approach toward LGBTQ+ individuals. Early in his papacy, he made headlines with his famous remark: “If someone is gay and is searching for the Lord and has good will, then who am I to judge him?”
However, his views on gay men in seminaries appear more conservative. In a closed-door meeting with Italian bishops in June, Pope Francis reportedly criticized the presence of homosexual behavior in seminaries, using a Roman slur to describe it. According to reports from two Italian newspapers, the pope expressed concern, saying, “There is already too much ‘frociaggine’ in the schools,” a term widely regarded as offensive.
Also Read:
- ABU to Honour Okonjo-Iweala and Sheikh Al-Hussain with Honorary Degrees
- Obasanjo – “I Went to Jail Because I Refused to Keep Quiet”
Mixed Reactions to the Guidelines
The new guidelines reflect the Church’s ongoing struggle to balance inclusivity with adherence to traditional teachings. While some see the move as a step toward greater acceptance, others criticize the restrictions as discriminatory.
Supporters of Pope Francis argue that his broader message of inclusion remains intact despite his reservations about homosexuality in seminaries. “Pope Francis has always advocated for love and respect for all people, regardless of their sexual orientation,” said an anonymous Vatican source.
Critics, however, argue that the restrictions perpetuate stigma. “By imposing such conditions, the Church sends a mixed message to LGBTQ+ Catholics who seek a place in its ministry,” said an Italian LGBTQ+ activist.
The Road Ahead
The guidelines reflect the Vatican’s official stance on homosexuality, which views same-sex acts as “intrinsically disordered.” However, Pope Francis’ papacy has encouraged dialogue about how the Church can better support LGBTQ+ individuals while staying true to its teachings.
As the Church navigates these complex issues, the debate over inclusivity and tradition is likely to continue, with many looking to Pope Francis for further guidance. For now, the guidelines serve as a reminder of the challenges faced by gay men seeking to answer their calling within the Catholic Church.